Stopping Corp-Internal Phishing Attacks with Darktrace
16
Jun 2021
16
Jun 2021
Discover how Darktrace Email stopped a series of multi-language phishing attacks, including an Emotet campaign in Japanese. Learn how Darktrace can help!
Language is deceptive. In the realm of email security, language can deceive a recipient into clicking a link or completing a transaction, and it can trick a security tool into thinking an email is legitimate.
It is for this reason that Darktrace/Email is not reliant on language, but rather uses mathematics to develop an understanding of ‘normal’ for every email user in an organization. This enables it to neutralize anomalous emails indicative of a threat around the world, no matter in what format or language they come.
Natural language processing
When it comes to catching a compromised account or impersonation email, how can you teach a computer to understand intent or a change of tone, compared to the normal way a person corresponds?
One of the most common approaches in email security is natural language processing. NLP looks at how to program computers to analyze natural language, commonly by exposing them to a large volume of data.
The result is a computer capable of ‘understanding’ the contents of documents, including the nuances of the language within them. The technology can then extract information in the documents as well as categorize and organize the documents themselves.
Modern-day limitations
However, using NLP is limited in scope for email security as it will often misunderstand specific jargon or colloquialisms, as well as terms that had not been invented when the computer was programmed, unless it is trained on these too. Each additional language requires the computer to learn from zero every time. NLP only works on the regional languages it has been trained on, and it is not commercially viable to teach the technology to work in all small markets.
If a company hires an email security vendor based in America, therefore, it is probable that the security vendor has invested most of their time in detecting English-based phishing threats. That is fine if the company only communicates in English, but this is often not the case. In a 21st century globalized world, the need for security technology to be language-agnostic is more critical than ever.
Not all AI is the same: Unsupervised machine learning
Darktrace/Email relies on unsupervised machine learning, which can learn on the job and does not need to be fed large data sets. It can glean insights from NLP for good measure, but it does not depend on NLP for detection or understanding.
When working with AI it is crucial to understand how the AI learns: does it learn on the job or was it trained with a labeled data set? This is particularly important when looking to understand the intent behind an email, specifically to uncover solicitation attempts either through spoofing, phishing, impersonation of a supplier or any other form of email attack.
Rather than teaching a computer to understand language in an email, Darktrace Cyber AI dynamically assesses activity across inbound and outbound emails including senders, recipients, links, IP addresses, and attachment types. The movement of all these objects are then used by the AI to create the ‘patterns of life’ for every user across all communications, including communications with external users who frequently correspond with a given business.
By taking a mathematical approach, Darktrace/Email is able to understand ‘normal’ for any user regardless of the dialect they are corresponding in, uniquely interpreting all languages from Norwegian to Latin and Persian, and subsequently identifying subtle anomalies indicative of a phishing attack or an account takeover.
Catching Emotet in Japanese
Last year, Darktrace uncovered a sophisticated Spamware campaign which leveraged Emotet, the infamous banking malware. The campaign targeted various industries with highly sophisticated phishing emails.
At a food production company in Japan, Darktrace detected six phishing emails sent over a two-day period in July.
In the email above, both the subject line and the filename translate to “Regarding the invoice,” followed by a number and the date. The attacker was clearly trying to imitate a legitimate business email here, spoofing a well-known Japanese company (三菱食品(株)) and a common Japanese name (‘藤沢 昭彦’).
Darktrace/Email revealed key metrics behind the email including that the real sender was using a domain name from GMO, a Japanese company which offers cheap web email services, and that the sender’s location was actually Portugal, not Japan.
Darktrace/Email’s models recognized the topic anomalies and inducement attempts in the emails, regardless of the language they had been written in – giving a high anomaly score of 85. Furthermore, Darktrace’s AI determined that the extension and the MIME type in the attachments were anomalous, when compared to the documents which the user normally exchanges via email.
Portuguese threat find
In another instance, a series of malicious emails were sent to an organization in Europe. These emails used several tactics to bypass the company’s security tools, including personalized subject lines and hidden malicious URLs.
As displayed above, the email contained a link that appeared to lead to a CaixaBank domain. However, Darktrace/Email recognized this as a deliberate attempt to mislead the recipient and revealed that the link in fact led to a WordPress domain, which Cyber AI identified as 100% rare for the business.
A closer inspection revealed that these emails were sent from Vietnam. The sender had never been in any previous correspondence with the business, and the isolated link within the email was also marked as a 100% rare domain. Darktrace/Email held these malicious emails back, protecting the organization from harm.
Universal defense
These two examples demonstrate the benefits of an unsupervised machine learning approach. An AI security solution which analyzes hundreds of different metrics and does not rely on pre-existing data is a groundbreaking advantage when faced with global phishing threats that now utilize a wide range of languages.
Email-based attacks are becoming more targeted and more convincing by the day. Targeted social engineering and spear phishing with advanced translation tools bombard companies daily, in all languages.
Whether it’s a phishing attack against a local office in Korea or a solicitation attempt in Arabic – even a malicious email written in Klingon from a Star Trek convention – or any of the thousands of email exchanges which occur in countless vernaculars and tones, Darktrace/Email can keep your company safe across the world, and beyond.
Like this and want more?
Receive the latest blog in your inbox
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
NEWSLETTER
Like this and want more?
Stay up to date on the latest industry news and insights.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Darktrace cyber analysts are world-class experts in threat intelligence, threat hunting and incident response, and provide 24/7 SOC support to thousands of Darktrace customers around the globe. Inside the SOC is exclusively authored by these experts, providing analysis of cyber incidents and threat trends, based on real-world experience in the field.
AUTHOR
ABOUT ThE AUTHOR
Mariana Pereira
VP, Cyber Innovation
Mariana is the VP of Cyber Innovation at Darktrace, and works closely with the development, analyst, and marketing teams to advise technical and non-technical audiences on how best to augment cyber resilience, and how to implement AI technology as a means of defense. She speaks regularly at international events, with a specialism in presenting on sophisticated, AI-powered email attacks. She holds an MBA from the University of Chicago, and speaks several languages including French, Italian, and Portuguese.
Connecting the Dots: Darktrace’s Detection of the Exploitation of the ConnectWise ScreenConnect Vulnerabilities
10
May 2024
Introduction
Across an ever changing cyber landscape, it is common place for threat actors to actively identify and exploit newly discovered vulnerabilities within commonly utilized services and applications. While attackers are likely to prioritize developing exploits for the more severe and global Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVEs), they typically have the most success exploiting known vulnerabilities within the first couple years of disclosure to the public.
Addressing these vulnerabilities in a timely manner reduces the effectiveness of known vulnerabilities, decreasing the pace of malicious actor operations and forcing pursuit of more costly and time-consuming methods, such as zero-day related exploits or attacking software supply chain operations. While actors also develop tools to exploit other vulnerabilities, developing exploits for critical and publicly known vulnerabilities gives actors impactful tools at a low cost they are able to use for quite some time.
Between January and March 2024, the Darktrace Threat Research team investigated one such example that involved indicators of compromise (IoCs) suggesting the exploitation of vulnerabilities in ConnectWise’s remote monitoring and management (RMM) software ScreenConnect.
What are the ConnectWise ScreenConnect vulnerabilities?
CVE-2024-1708 is an authentication bypass vulnerability in ScreenConnect 23.9.7 (and all earlier versions) that, if exploited, would enable an attacker to execute remote code or directly impact confidential information or critical systems. This exploit would pave the way for a second ScreenConnect vunerability, CVE-2024-1709, which allows attackers to directly access confidential information or critical systems [1].
ConnectWise released a patch and automatically updated cloud versions of ScreenConnect 23.9.9, while urging security temas to update on-premise versions immediately [3].
If exploited in conjunction, these vulnerabilities could allow a malicious actor to create new administrative accounts on publicly exposed instances by evading existing security measures. This, in turn, could enable attackers to assume an administrative role and disable security tools, create backdoors, and disrupt RMM processes. Access to an organization’s environment in this manner poses serious risk, potentially leading to significant consequences such as deploying ransomware, as seen in various incidents involving the exploitation of ScreenConnect [2]
Darktrace’s anomaly-based detection was able to identify evidence of exploitation related to CVE-2024-1708 and CVE-2024-1709 across two distinct timelines; these detections included connectivity with endpoints that were later confirmed to be malicious by multiple open-source intelligence (OSINT) vendors. The activity observed by Darktrace suggests that threat actors were actively exploiting these vulnerabilities across multiple customer environments.
In the cases observed across the Darktrace fleet, Darktrace DETECT™ and Darktrace RESPOND™ were able to work in tandem to pre-emptively identify and contain network compromises from the onset. While Darktrace RESPOND was enabled in most customer environments affected by the ScreenConnect vulnerabilities, in the majority of cases it was configured in Human Confirmation mode. Whilst in Human Confirmation mode, RESPOND will provide recommended actions to mitigate ongoing attacks, but these actions require manual approval from human security teams.
When enabled in autonomous response mode, Darktrace RESPOND will take action automatically, shutting down suspicious activity as soon as it is detected without the need for human intervention. This is the ideal end state for RESPOND as actions can be taken at machine speed, without any delays waiting for user approval.
Looking within the patterns of activity observed by Darktrace , the typical attack timeline included:
Darktrace observed devices on affected customer networks performing activity indicative of ConnectWise ScreenConnect usage, for example connections over 80 and 8041, connections to screenconnect[.]com, and the use of the user agent “LabTech Agent”. OSINT research suggests that this user agent is an older name for ConnectWise Automate [5] which also includes ScreenConnect as standard [6].
This activity was typically followed by anomalous connections to the external IP address 108.61.210[.]72 using URIs of the form “/MyUserName_DEVICEHOSTNAME”, as well as additional connections to another external, IP 185.62.58[.]132. Both of these external locations have since been reported as potentially malicious [14], with 185.62.58[.]132 in particular linked to ScreenConnect post-exploitation activity [2].
Same Exploit, Different Tactics?
While the majority of instances of ConnectWise ScreenConnect exploitation observed by Darktrace followed the above pattern of activity, Darktrace was able to identify some deviations from this.
In one customer environment, Darktrace’s detection of post-exploitation activity began with the same indicators of ScreenConnect usage, including connections to screenconnect[.]com via port 8041, followed by connections to unusual domains flagged as malicious by OSINT, in this case 116.0.56[.]101 [16] [17]. However, on this deployment Darktrace also observed threat actors downloading a suspicious AnyDesk installer from the endpoint with the URI “hxxp[:]//116.0.56[.]101[:]9191/images/Distribution.exe”.
Further investigation by Darktrace’s Threat Research team revealed that this endpoint was associated with threat actors exploiting CVE-2024-1708 and CVE-2024-1709 [1]. Darktrace was additionally able to identify that, despite the customer being based in the United Kingdom, the file downloaded came from Pakistan. Darktrace recognized that this represented a deviation from the device’s expected pattern of activity and promptly alerted for it, bringing it to the attention of the customer.
Darktrace’s Autonomous Response
In this instance, the customer had Darktrace enabled in autonomous response mode and the post-exploitation activity was swiftly contained, preventing the attack from escalating.
As soon as the suspicious AnyDesk download was detected, Darktrace RESPOND applied targeted measures to prevent additional malicious activity. This included blocking connections to 116.0.56[.]101 and “*.56.101”, along with blocking all outgoing traffic from the device. Furthermore, RESPOND enforced a “pattern of life” on the device, restricting its activity to its learned behavior, allowing connections that are considered normal, but blocking any unusual deviations.
The customer was later able to use RESPOND to manually quarantine the offending device, ensuring that all incoming and outgoing traffic to or from the device was prohibited, thus preventing ay further malicious communication or lateral movement attempts.
Conclusion
In the observed cases of the ConnectWise ScreenConnect vulnerabilities being exploited across the Darktrace fleet, Darktrace was able to pre-emptively identify and contain network compromises from the onset, offering vital protection against disruptive cyber-attacks.
While much of the post-exploitation activity observed by Darktrace remained the same across different customer environments, important deviations were also identified suggesting that threat actors may be adapting their tactics, techniques and procedures (TTPs) from campaign to campaign.
While new vulnerabilities will inevitably surface and threat actors will continually look for novel ways to evolve their methods, Darktrace’s Self-Learning AI and behavioral analysis offers organizations full visibility over new or unknown threats. Rather than relying on existing threat intelligence or static lists of “known bads”, Darktrace is able to detect emerging activity based on anomaly and respond to it without latency, safeguarding customer environments whilst causing minimal disruption to business operations.
Credit: Emma Foulger, Principal Cyber Analyst for their contribution to this blog.
Appendices
Darktrace Model Coverage
DETECT Models
Compromise / Agent Beacon (Medium Period)
Compromise / Agent Beacon (Long Period)
Anomalous File / EXE from Rare External Location
Device / New PowerShell User Agent
Anomalous Connection / Powershell to Rare External
Anomalous Connection / New User Agent to IP Without Hostname
User / New Admin Credentials on Client
Device / New User Agent
Anomalous Connection / Multiple HTTP POSTs to Rare Hostname
Anomalous Server Activity / Anomalous External Activity from Critical Network Device
Compromise / Suspicious Request Data
Compliance / Remote Management Tool On Server
Anomalous File / Anomalous Octet Stream (No User Agent)
How Empowering End Users can Improve Your Email Security and Decrease the Burden on the SOC
08
May 2024
Why do we pay attention to the end user?
Every email security solution filters inbound mail, then typically hands over false positives and false negatives to the security team for manual triage. A crucial problem with this lifecycle is that it ignores the inevitability of end users being at the front line of any organization. Employees may receive point in time security awareness training, but it is rarely engaging or contextualized to their reality. While an employee may report a suspicious-looking email to the security team, they will rarely get to understand the outcome or impact of that decision. This means that the quality of reporting never improves, so the burden on the security team of triaging these emails – of which 90% are falsely reported – persists and grows with the business over time.
At Darktrace, we recognize that employees will always be on the front line of email security. That’s why we aim to improve end-user reporting from the ground up, reducing the overall number of emails needing triage and saving security team resource.
How does Darktrace improve the quality of end-user reporting?
Darktrace prioritizes improving users’ security awareness to increase the quality of end-user reporting from day one. We train users and optimize their experience, which in turn provides better detection.
That starts with training and security awareness. Traditionally, organizations oblige employees to attend point-in-time training sessions which interrupt their daily work schedules. With Darktrace/Email, if a message contains some potentially suspicious markers but is most likely safe, Darktrace takes a specific action to neutralize the risky components and presents it to the user with a simple narrative explaining why certain elements have been held back. The user can then decide whether to report this email to the security team.
The AI narrative gives the user context for why their specific email may carry risk, putting their security awareness training into practice. This creates an element of trust with the security solution, rather than viewing it as outside of daily workflows. Users may also receive a daily or weekly digest of their held emails and make a decision on whether to release or report them.
Whatever the user’s existing workflow is for reporting emails, Darktrace/Email can integrate with it and improve its quality. Our add-in for Outlook gives users a fully optimized experience, allowing them to engage with the narratives for each email, as well as non-productive mail management. However, if teams want to integrate Darktrace into an existing workflow, it can analyze emails reported to an internal SOC mailbox, the native email provider’s 'Report Phish’ button, or the ‘Knowbe4’ button.
By empowering the user with contextual feedback on each unique email, we foster employee engagement and elevate both reporting quality and security awareness. In fact, 60% fewer benign emails are reported because of the extra context supplied by Darktrace to end users. The eventual report is then fed back to the detection algorithm, improving future decision-making.
Reducing the amount of emails that reach the SOC
Out of the higher-quality emails that do end up being reported by users, the next step is to reduce the amount of emails that reach the SOC.
Once a user reports an email, Darktrace will independently determine if the mail should be automatically remediated based on second level triage. Darktrace/Email’s Mailbox Security Assistant automates secondary triage by combining additional behavioral signals and the most advanced link analysis engine we have ever built. It detects 70% more sophisticated malicious phishing links by looking at an additional twenty times more context than at the primary analysis stage, revealing the hidden intent within interactive and dynamic webpages. This directly alleviates the burden of manual triage for security analysts.
Following this secondary triage the emails that are deemed worthy of security team attention are then passed over, resulting in a lower quantity and higher quality of emails for SOC manual triage.
Centralizing and speeding analysis for investigations
For those emails that are received by the SOC, Darktrace also helps to improve triage time for manual remediation.
AI-generated narratives and automated remediation actions empower teams to fast-track manual triage and remediation, while still providing security analysts with the necessary depth. With live inbox view, security teams gain access to a centralized platform that combines intuitive search capabilities, Cyber AI Analyst reports, and mobile application access. With all security workflows consolidated within a unified interface, users can analyze and take remediation actions without the need to navigate multiple tools, such as e-discovery platforms – eliminating console hopping and accelerating incident response.
Our customers tell us that our AI allows them to go in-depth quickly for investigations, versus other solutions that only provide a high-level view.
Conclusion
Unlike our competitors, we believe that improving the quality of users’ experience is not only a nice-to-have, but a fundamental means for improving security. Any modern solution should consider end users as a key source of information as well as an opportunity for defense. Darktrace does both – optimizing the user experience as well as our AI learning from the user to augment detection.
The benefits of empowering users are ultimately felt by the security team, who benefit from improved detection, a reduction in manual triage of benign emails, and faster investigation workflows.
Augmented end user reporting is just one of a range of features new to Darktrace/Email. Check out the latest Innovations to Darktrace/Email in our recent blog.