Startups

When should an early-stage startup hire a full-time lawyer?

Comment

A clock face hat displays equations instead of numerals on white background.
Image Credits: malerapaso (opens in a new window) / Getty Images (Image has been modified)

Kristen Corpion

Contributor

Kristen Corpion is the founder of CORPlaw, a Miami-based law firm serving fast-growing technology companies and entrepreneurs as fractional general counsel.

More posts from Kristen Corpion

Most fast-growing startups get by for long periods of time before hiring their first in-house lawyer. It’s not that startups don’t have important legal work that needs to get done. But in the early stages of growth, it almost always makes sense to outsource all legal work. It’s a matter of allocation of scarce resources, and most early-stage startups can get by with outside counsel alone.

So when is the right time to hire an in-house lawyer? There’s both an art and a science to the decision. Let’s dig in and consider some of the key factors.

Is there enough legal work to keep a full-time lawyer busy?

It may seem like your startup is dealing with a lot of legal work, but carefully consider whether it’s enough work (30 to 40 hours a week) to keep a full-time lawyer busy. And even if there is that much work at the moment, determine whether it’s driven by an atypical circumstance (e.g., litigation) that is leading to a big but temporary outside counsel spend.

It’s better to hire your first in-house lawyer when it hurts a bit — when you start to feel stretched thin — rather than too early in your business’ lifecycle. Unlike with some other roles that may need filling, you can find highly competent outside lawyers to bridge the gap as you grow into needing full-time support. But don’t wait too long – legal issues can impact an organization’s efficiency, with the burden being felt most acutely by the founder and key executives.

As a general rule of thumb, plan to hire when your outside legal fees reach approximately two times the amount it will cost to employ a good in-house lawyer, who should be able to take on quite a bit of the work currently being outsourced and more effectively manage outside legal support.

When evaluating your current legal spend, you should consider whether your company has been under-investing in legal issues such as contracts, intellectual property and employment policies. There may be more legal work than you think — it’s just being deferred, and an in-house lawyer will have to clean things up.

There’s also the work of building legal systems, processes and strategy that won’t get the attention it deserves until you bring someone in-house. Accordingly, when you’re trying to determine whether there’s enough work to support a full-time lawyer, take into account the work that may not be getting done but needs to be to support your growth.

Finally, evaluate whether you or members of your team are spending too much time “playing” lawyer. Even if you’ve managed to get by, at some point the volume of legal issues will catch up with you, and you won’t be able to keep up. And even if you could, your time is almost certainly better spent improving and scaling the business.

What specialties should we look for in an in-house lawyer?

It would be nice if hiring your first in-house lawyer meant that all of your outside legal fees would go away, but that’s not realistic. Startups that reach a $1 billion valuation are called unicorns because they’re like mythical creatures, and the same goes for an in-house lawyer who can do everything.

The reality is that your in-house lawyer will likely have expertise in a couple of key legal disciplines (e.g., transactions and commercial contracts), be competent enough to get by in a few others (litigation, securities law) and have little to no experience in many other areas (IP, tax, etc.).

In other words, the odds are that you won’t find a Jack- or Jill-of-all-trades (a unicorn) who excels at handling all the legal work you need to be done. What’s necessary, therefore, is evaluating the nature and composition — not just the amount — of your company’s legal work.

If it’s broadly distributed across many different legal disciplines, it means you’ll probably be holding off a bit longer before hiring a lawyer in-house. On the other hand, if the work is highly concentrated in one or two areas, such as IP, then an in-house hire may make more sense in the short term because one lawyer with relevant specialized expertise can shoulder more of the company’s legal work.

The only way to truly know how concentrated a company’s legal work is is to print off a year’s worth of legal bills and have them scrutinized to determine the nature of the work that underlies all those itemized time entries. When I conduct this sort of analysis for clients, they’re often shocked to learn how much they’re spending on legal, with whom and for what. The process can not only inform hiring decisions but also help optimize outside legal spend.

Perhaps most important of all, when thinking about the skill set you need in an in-house lawyer, consider what legal issues are coming in the future, not just those you’ve dealt with in the past. Legal challenges will change depending on where your company is at in its lifecycle and the execution of its strategy.

For example, if you’re running a ride-hailing startup that is operating in one city, but has plans to scale across the country, and ultimately around the world, litigation may not be consuming many of your current resources. You would be wise, however, as a company in a regulated industry, to anticipate all of those legal battles with local governments to come, and perhaps shift your in-house lawyer hiring strategy accordingly.

Is the volume of legal issues rapidly increasing?

One of the signs that you’re ready to hire in-house counsel is a steady increase in the number and significance of legal matters, such as lawsuits and contracts, that require attention. These issues can sometimes be framed as “good problems to have” — the cost of doing business for a high-growth company. But they’re problems that need to be addressed nonetheless.

One of the key reasons to consider hiring in-house counsel when there’s a steady uptick in the velocity of these types of legal issues is that a dedicated lawyer can help stem them. A good in-house lawyer will set up systems and processes, such as litigation avoidance and contract lifecycle management strategies, that serve as upstream solutions that prevent downstream legal headaches.

For example, in my experience helping startups to build out their in-house legal teams, I’ve seen what a big impact an in-house lawyer can have, in terms of bringing down costs and increasing efficiency, through the implementation of a more streamlined process for the negotiation, documentation and management of commercial contracts. An in-house lawyer can help a startup transition from an ad-hoc approach to contracts to a structured one, resulting in fewer legal fees, fewer risks and more deals getting done.

Is there institutional buy-in for an in-house lawyer?

When weighing the pros and cons of bringing on an in-house lawyer, don’t think about it merely in economic terms. Adding a smart, confident in-house lawyer to your team will necessarily change how you do business. The change should be positive, but you still need to make sure your organization is ready for it.

As discussed previously, a good in-house lawyer will start implementing more legal systems and processes in order to protect the business as it grows. They will ask lots of questions. They may slow certain things down — such as the review and negotiation of an important contract — when you and your team are used to moving really fast.

If you’re not ready to embrace this sort of maturation in the business, then you’re probably not ready for an in-house lawyer. The last thing you want is to bring someone on because it makes economic sense, but there’s no institutional buy-in to change how the business runs. If your company’s culture is one that believes that lawyers are obstacles to progress rather than enablers of it, you may have to work on the culture before making the hire.

Every startup needs a lawyer — but not necessarily an in-house lawyer from day one. A good deal of thought, strategy and analysis should go into the decision. When we help our startup clients prepare for their first in-house lawyer, we remind them that they’re not just looking for a great lawyer, but also someone who has the management and leadership skills necessary to make a positive impact on the business.

It’s not easy. It’s not to be taken lightly. It’s critical to map out needs and expectations in advance. But if done at the right time in the business’ growth, for the right reasons, and with institutional buy-in, a startup’s first in-house lawyer can be an asset that can help the business soar to new heights.

More TechCrunch

Sona, a workforce management platform for frontline employees, has raised $27.5 million in a Series A round of funding. More than two-thirds of the U.S. workforce are reportedly in frontline…

Sona, a frontline workforce management platform, raises $27.5M with eyes on US expansion

Uber Technologies announced Tuesday that it will buy the Taiwan unit of Delivery Hero’s Foodpanda for $950 million in cash. The deal is part of Uber Eats’ strategy to expand…

Uber to acquire Foodpanda’s Taiwan unit from Delivery Hero for $950M in cash 

Paris-based Blisce has become the latest VC firm to launch a fund dedicated to climate tech. It plans to raise as much as €150M (about $162M).

Paris-based VC firm Blisce launches climate tech fund with a target of $160M

Maad, a B2B e-commerce startup based in Senegal, has secured $3.2 million debt-equity funding to bolster its growth in the western Africa country and to explore fresh opportunities in the…

Maad raises $3.2M seed amid B2B e-commerce sector turbulence in Africa

The fresh funds were raised from two investors who transferred the capital into a special purpose vehicle, a legal entity associated with the OpenAI Startup Fund.

OpenAI Startup Fund raises additional $5M

Accel has invested in more than 200 startups in the region to date, making it one of the more prolific VCs in this market.

Accel has a fresh $650M to back European early-stage startups

Kyle Vogt, the former founder and CEO of self-driving car company Cruise, has a new VC-backed robotics startup focused on household chores. Vogt announced Monday that the new startup, called…

Cruise founder Kyle Vogt is back with a robot startup

When Keith Rabois announced he was leaving Founders Fund to return to Khosla Ventures in January, it came as a shock to many in the venture capital ecosystem — and…

From Miles Grimshaw to Eva Ho, venture capitalists continue to play musical chairs

On the heels of OpenAI announcing the latest iteration of its GPT large language model, its biggest rival in generative AI in the U.S. announced an expansion of its own.…

Anthropic is expanding to Europe and raising more money

If you’re looking for a Starliner mission recap, you’ll have to wait a little longer, because the mission has officially been delayed.

TechCrunch Space: You rock(et) my world, moms

Apple devoted a full event to iPad last Tuesday, roughly a month out from WWDC. From the invite artwork to the polarizing ad spot, Apple was clear — the event…

Apple iPad Pro M4 vs. iPad Air M2: Reviewing which is right for most

Terri Burns, a former partner at GV, is venturing into a new chapter of her career by launching her own venture firm called Type Capital. 

GV’s youngest partner has launched her own firm

The decision to go monochrome was probably a smart one, considering the candy-colored alternatives that seem to want to dazzle and comfort you.

ChatGPT’s new face is a black hole

Apple and Google announced on Monday that iPhone and Android users will start seeing alerts when it’s possible that an unknown Bluetooth device is being used to track them. The…

Apple and Google agree on standard to alert people when unknown Bluetooth devices may be tracking them

The company is describing the event as “a chance to demo some ChatGPT and GPT-4 updates.”

OpenAI’s ChatGPT announcement: Watch here

A human safety operator will be behind the wheel during this phase of testing, according to the company.

GM’s Cruise ramps up robotaxi testing in Phoenix

OpenAI announced a new flagship generative AI model on Monday that they call GPT-4o — the “o” stands for “omni,” referring to the model’s ability to handle text, speech, and…

OpenAI debuts GPT-4o ‘omni’ model now powering ChatGPT

Featured Article

The women in AI making a difference

As a part of a multi-part series, TechCrunch is highlighting women innovators — from academics to policymakers —in the field of AI.

17 hours ago
The women in AI making a difference

The expansion of Polar Semiconductor’s facility would enable the company to double its U.S. production capacity of sensor and power chips within two years.

White House proposes up to $120M to help fund Polar Semiconductor’s chip facility expansion

In 2021, Google kicked off work on Project Starline, a corporate-focused teleconferencing platform that uses 3D imaging, cameras and a custom-designed screen to let people converse with someone as if…

Google’s 3D video conferencing platform, Project Starline, is coming in 2025 with help from HP

Over the weekend, Instagram announced that it is expanding its creator marketplace to 10 new countries — this marketplace connects brands with creators to foster collaboration. The new regions include…

Instagram expands its creator marketplace to 10 new countries

You can expect plenty of AI, but probably not a lot of hardware.

Google I/O 2024: What to expect

The keynote kicks off at 10 a.m. PT on Tuesday and will offer glimpses into the latest versions of Android, Wear OS and Android TV.

Google I/O 2024: How to watch

Four-year-old Mexican BNPL startup Aplazo facilitates fractionated payments to offline and online merchants even when the buyer doesn’t have a credit card.

Aplazo is using buy now, pay later as a stepping stone to financial ubiquity in Mexico

We received countless submissions to speak at this year’s Disrupt 2024. After carefully sifting through all the applications, we’ve narrowed it down to 19 session finalists. Now we need your…

Vote for your Disrupt 2024 Audience Choice favs

Co-founder and CEO Bowie Cheung, who previously worked at Uber Eats, said the company now has 200 customers.

Healthy growth helps B2B food e-commerce startup Pepper nab $30 million led by ICONIQ Growth

Booking.com has been designated a gatekeeper under the EU’s DMA, meaning the firm will be regulated under the bloc’s market fairness framework.

Booking.com latest to fall under EU market power rules

Featured Article

‘Got that boomer!’: How cybercriminals steal one-time passcodes for SIM swap attacks and raiding bank accounts

Estate is an invite-only website that has helped hundreds of attackers make thousands of phone calls aimed at stealing account passcodes, according to its leaked database.

22 hours ago
‘Got that boomer!’: How cybercriminals steal one-time passcodes for SIM swap attacks and raiding bank accounts

Squarespace is being taken private in an all-cash deal that values the company on an equity basis at $6.6 billion.

Permira is taking Squarespace private in a $6.9 billion deal

AI-powered tools like OpenAI’s Whisper have enabled many apps to make transcription an integral part of their feature set for personal note-taking, and the space has quickly flourished as a…

Buy Me a Coffee’s founder has built an AI-powered voice note app